A petition for reconsideration under Omani law is an extraordinary method of challenge brought before the same court that issued the final judgment. It is available only in the seven cases set out in Article 232 of the Civil and Commercial Procedure Law issued by Royal Decree 29/2002, the most notable being fraud, forgery, false testimony and the discovery of a document the opponent had withheld. The deadline is thirty days, which in most cases runs from the day the ground is discovered rather than the day the judgment is issued, and filing it does not suspend enforcement of the judgment unless the court so orders.
This article explains in plain terms which judgments can be the subject of a petition, its grounds, how the deadline is calculated, the competent court, its effect on enforcement and the consequences of its dismissal, based on the amended text of the law.
What is a petition for reconsideration?
A petition is not a second appeal or a chance to argue the case again. It is an exceptional means of correcting a final judgment based on a serious defect that the losing party could not have discovered or remedied while the case was being heard, for example where it emerges after the judgment that the documents relied on were forged, or that the opponent concealed a decisive document. For this reason it is brought before the same court that issued the judgment, which may sit with the same judges who issued it, unlike an appeal, which goes to a higher court.
Which judgments can be the subject of a petition?
Article 232 provides that the parties may petition for reconsideration of judgments issued in the last instance, meaning judgments that can no longer be appealed. Examples include:
- Judgments of the Courts of Appeal on appeals brought before them.
- Judgments of the Court of First Instance sitting with a single judge in claims of assessable value not exceeding OMR 1,000, since its judgment is final under Article 37.
- Judgments of the first-instance circuit in disputes governed by the Litigation Procedures Simplification Law (in Arabic) (such as individual labour disputes, rent disputes and building contracts) where the value of the claim does not exceed OMR 2,000, because Article 11 of that law permits an appeal only above that value, with specific exceptions in Article 12.
By contrast, a petition is not permitted in the following cases:
- Judgments of the Supreme Court, because Article 263 provides that they cannot be challenged by any method of challenge.
- A judgment declaring a petition inadmissible or dismissing it, and a judgment on the merits issued after a petition is admitted, under Article 238; there can be no petition against a petition.
- A judgment that can still be appealed; the correct route in that case is an appeal within its deadline.
The seven grounds for a petition for reconsideration
Article 232 sets out the cases in which a petition is admissible:
- Fraud by the opponent: where the opponent committed fraud capable of affecting the judgment.
- Forgery or false testimony: where the judgment was based on documents that, after it was issued, were admitted to be forged or were found by a court to be forged, or on the testimony of a witness that a court found, after the judgment, to be false testimony.
- Discovery of a withheld decisive document: where, after the judgment was issued, the petitioner obtained decisive documents in the case that the opponent had prevented from being submitted.
- A judgment on matters not requested: where the judgment awarded something the parties did not request, or more than they requested.
- Improper representation: where the judgment was issued against a natural or legal person who was not properly represented in the case.
- A third party bound by the judgment: for a person against whom the judgment is binding who was not joined in or did not intervene in the case, provided they prove fraud, collusion or gross negligence by the person who represented them.
- A self-contradictory operative part: where parts of the operative part of the judgment contradict each other.
All these grounds concern a specific defect in the judgment or in how it was reached, and they do not include an error in applying the law or in assessing the evidence. Disagreement with the judgment alone is not enough for a petition to be admitted.
The deadline for a petition for reconsideration and when it starts
Article 233 provides that the period for a petition is thirty days, but the starting point differs according to the ground:
- Fraud, forgery, false testimony and a withheld document (items a, b and c): the period runs from the day the fraud came to light, the day the person responsible admitted the forgery or it was established by a judgment, the day judgment was given against the false witness, or the day the withheld document came to light.
- Improper representation (item e): it runs from the day the judgment is notified to the losing party or to the person who properly represents them.
- A third party bound by the judgment (item f): it runs from the day the fraud, collusion or gross negligence came to light.
- A judgment on matters not requested and a self-contradictory operative part (items d and g): Article 233 sets no special starting point for these, so the general rule in Article 204 applies, namely that the period for a challenge runs from the day after the judgment is issued, or from the day after it is notified in the cases set out in that article, such as where the losing party failed to attend all hearings and did not submit a defence memorandum.
In personal status matters the period is much shorter: only ten days, starting according to the same rules in Article 233, under Article 279.
Missing the deadline is decisive. Article 206 provides that failure to observe the time limits for a challenge results in loss of the right to challenge, and the court declares this of its own motion even if the opponent does not raise it. Documenting the date on which the fraud was discovered or the document came to light is therefore essential, because the opponent will usually dispute that date.
Which court hears the petition and how is it filed?
The petition is brought before the court that issued the judgment under Article 234, and usually goes through the following steps:
- Check that the judgment is final, that the ground genuinely falls within one of the seven cases, and that the deadline has not expired.
- Gather evidence of the ground and the date it came to light, such as the judgment establishing the forgery or against the false witness, or the document that came to light after the judgment and evidence that the opponent prevented its submission.
- Prepare the statement of petition, which must contain details of the judgment challenged, its date and the grounds of the petition, failing which it is void.
- File the statement with the court registry in accordance with the rules and procedures for bringing a claim. Article 5 of the Litigation Procedures Simplification Law allows statements of claim and of challenge to be filed through the designated electronic systems in accordance with the approved rules.
- If the ground is improper representation or the petitioner is a third party (items e and f), the security must be deposited under Article 212, which is OMR 50 according to the text of that article.
How does the court hear the petition?
Under Article 236, the court first decides whether the petition is admissible, meaning whether its conditions are met as regards the judgment, the ground and the deadline. If it admits the petition, it sets a hearing for argument on the merits without the need for fresh notification, and it may decide admissibility and the merits in a single judgment if the parties have made their submissions on the merits. The court reconsiders only the requests covered by the petition, so the whole dispute is not reopened.
Does a petition for reconsideration suspend enforcement of the judgment?
The rule in Article 235 is that filing a petition does not suspend enforcement of the judgment. However, the court hearing the petition may order a suspension of enforcement if the petitioner requests it and enforcement is likely to cause serious harm that would be difficult to remedy. When ordering a suspension, the court may require security to be provided or order whatever it considers sufficient to protect the rights of the party against whom the petition is brought.
In practice this means that the party who won the judgment can proceed with enforcement unless a suspension order is issued, and that a request for suspension should be made early and supported by evidence of the seriousness of the harm. See our enforcement of judgments service for matters relating to the enforcement stage.
What follows if the petition is dismissed?
- If a petition based on items a, b, c, d or g is dismissed, the petitioner is ordered to pay a fine of not less than OMR 10 and not more than OMR 25 (Article 237).
- If a petition based on items e or f is dismissed, the court orders all or part of the security to be forfeited.
- In all cases, damages may be awarded where justified.
- A judgment dismissing a petition or declaring it inadmissible cannot itself be challenged by a further petition (Article 238).
How can a lawyer help with a petition for reconsideration?
The difficulty of a petition lies in its narrow grounds and short deadline, and a mistake in characterising the ground or fixing the date the period starts can lose the right for good. The judicial and legal representation in Muscat team at Dr. Abdullah Al Rashdi Office, Advocates and Legal Consultants studies the judgment and assesses whether a ground for a petition exists, prepares and files the statement of petition, requests a suspension of enforcement where needed, and argues the case before the court. You can also consult the full text of the Civil and Commercial Procedure Law (as amended) (in Arabic) on our website.
If a final judgment has been issued against you and you believe it was based on fraud, forgery or a withheld document, do not wait until the deadline passes. Contact us on WhatsApp or call +968 92000841, or visit our office in Al Khuwair, Muscat.
Frequently asked questions
Can a petition for reconsideration be brought against a Supreme Court judgment?
No. Article 263 of the Civil and Commercial Procedure Law provides that judgments of the Supreme Court cannot be challenged by any method of challenge.
What is the deadline for a petition for reconsideration in personal status cases?
Ten days under Article 279, starting according to the rules in Article 233. The petition is brought by a statement filed with the registry of the court that issued the judgment or decision. For more details, see our personal status cases service.
Can a petition be filed because the judge misapplied the law?
An error in applying the law is not one of the seven cases listed in Article 232. This type of error is usually addressed by an appeal, or by a challenge before the Supreme Court, where that is permitted and within its deadline.
What is the difference between a petition for reconsideration and an appeal?
An appeal is an ordinary method of challenge brought before a higher court against first-instance judgments that can be appealed, and it puts the dispute forward to be decided afresh. A petition is brought before the same court against a final judgment, on exhaustively specified grounds, and the court reconsiders only the requests covered by the petition.
This article is general legal information based on the published provisions and is not legal advice on a particular case, as the outcome depends on the facts of each case, the date of the judgment and any amendments to the legislation. We therefore recommend consulting Dr. Abdullah Al Rashdi Office before taking any action.

