A grievance against an enforcement judge's decision under Omani law is the route by which a person concerned challenges a decision issued by the enforcement judge. Its best-known form is the grievance against an imprisonment order, which is submitted by petition to the competent Court of Appeal; the court decides it in chambers within 7 days by a final decision under Article 418 of the Civil and Commercial Procedure Law. Judgments that the enforcement judge issues in enforcement disputes, including enforcement objections, are instead challenged by appeal within 7 days under Article 339. A grievance does not suspend enforcement of the decision unless the court orders it.
This article explains in plain terms who may file a grievance, which decisions can be challenged, the deadlines, the competent court, and the difference between a grievance and an enforcement objection, based on the Civil and Commercial Procedure Law (as amended) (in Arabic) issued by Royal Decree 29/2002. If you have an open enforcement file, an enforcement of judgments lawyer in Muscat can review your position before the deadlines pass.
Who is the enforcement judge and what is their jurisdiction?
Article 334 provides that enforcement is carried out under the supervision of an enforcement judge assigned at the seat of each Court of First Instance from among its judges, assisted by a sufficient number of bailiffs. Article 335 provides that the enforcement judge alone has jurisdiction to decide all substantive and interim enforcement disputes, whatever their value, and decides interim disputes in the capacity of a judge of urgent matters.
In the course of an enforcement file the enforcement judge issues two kinds of acts, which must be distinguished because the route of challenge differs:
- Judgments deciding an enforcement dispute brought before the judge, such as a judgment on an interim enforcement objection or on a substantive dispute.
- Decisions and orders issued to move enforcement forward, such as an order imprisoning a judgment debtor who refuses to comply, an order to sell attached property, or permission to enter real property to describe it.
Decisions that can be challenged and the route for each
Omani law has no single general provision for a grievance against everything the enforcement judge issues. Instead, it sets the route of challenge according to the type of decision. The main cases are as follows:
1. An order imprisoning the judgment debtor (Article 418)
Article 418 allows the court that issued the order, and the enforcement judge, to order the imprisonment of a judgment debtor who refuses to comply with a judicial order or an enforceable judgment, for a period of up to two months that may be renewed, provided it does not exceed 6 consecutive months if the debtor has a settled residence. The second paragraph provides that persons concerned may file a grievance against this decision by a petition submitted to the competent Court of Appeal, or to the court that issued it, which must refer it to the Court of Appeal, to be decided in chambers within 7 days of its submission or referral, and its decision is final. A grievance does not suspend enforcement of the imprisonment order unless the Court of Appeal orders a suspension.
A grievance is particularly useful here where one of the cases in which imprisonment is barred under Article 424 applies, such as where the judgment debtor is under eighteen or over seventy, provides a bank guarantee or a solvent guarantor, or discloses assets in the Sultanate sufficient to pay the debt.
2. Judgments in enforcement disputes, including enforcement objections (Article 339)
These are not challenged by grievance but by appeal. Judgments of the enforcement judge in substantive disputes are appealed to the Court of First Instance sitting as a panel of three judges if the value of the dispute exceeds OMR 1,000 and does not exceed OMR 3,000, and to the Court of Appeal if it exceeds that amount. Judgments in interim disputes are appealed to the Court of First Instance sitting as a panel of three judges. The appeal period is 7 days from the date the judgment is issued if it was rendered in the appellant's presence, and from the date of notification if it was issued in the appellant's absence. An appeal suspends enforcement proceedings until the court decides the dispute.
3. A grievance before the enforcement judge on security (Article 351)
Where enforcement is permitted only against security, the person concerned may, within 3 days of notification of the choice made by the party required to provide security, file a grievance before the enforcement judge disputing the solvency of the guarantor, the reliability of the custodian or the sufficiency of what is deposited. The decision on this grievance is final.
4. Orders that cannot be challenged by grievance
The law expressly bars a grievance against certain orders of the enforcement judge, including an order permitting the enforcement bailiff to enter real property to describe it and identify its contents (Article 397), and an order to publish additional notices of the sale of real property (Article 402).
Who may file a grievance?
The provision gives the right of grievance to "persons concerned", meaning anyone directly affected by the decision. With an imprisonment order, the person filing is usually the judgment debtor, and an agent holding a power of attorney may file on their behalf. If the judgment debtor is a legal person such as a company, imprisonment under Article 421 is ordered against the individual personally responsible for the refusal to comply, who may then file a grievance against the decision issued against them.
How is a grievance filed? Practical steps
- Obtain a copy of the decision being challenged and the enforcement file number, and identify its type: is it an imprisonment order, a judgment in an enforcement dispute, or another order? The route of challenge and the time limit depend on this.
- Draft the grievance petition with the details of the parties and the decision and clear grounds, such as payment of all or part of the debt, proven insolvency, the existence of a bar to imprisonment, or a procedural error.
- Attach the supporting documents: the decision, proof of identity, the power of attorney if the grievance is filed through an agent, and any payment receipts or guarantees.
- Submit the petition to the competent Court of Appeal or to the court that issued the decision. The Supreme Judicial Council offers, through the government portal (gov.om), an electronic service for filing a grievance against an enforcement judge's decision and a separate service for a grievance against an imprisonment order.
- If continued enforcement would harm you, expressly ask in the petition for enforcement of the decision to be suspended, because a grievance does not suspend it automatically.
- Follow up on the file, since a grievance against imprisonment must be decided within 7 days of its submission or referral to the Court of Appeal.
What is the deadline for a grievance?
The deadline depends on the type of decision. The period for appealing judgments of the enforcement judge is 7 days (Article 339), and the period for a grievance on security is 3 days (Article 351). Article 418, on imprisonment orders, sets a period of 7 days for the Court of Appeal to decide the grievance, not for filing it, and we found no express deadline in it for filing. However, imprisonment is carried out immediately and is not suspended by a grievance, so filing as soon as possible is the only practical option.
The difference between a grievance against an enforcement judge's decision and an enforcement objection
The two routes are often confused, although each has a different purpose and forum:
- Subject: a grievance is directed at a decision the judge has already issued, such as an imprisonment order. An enforcement objection is directed at the enforcement proceedings themselves and seeks an interim measure, such as suspending or continuing enforcement.
- Forum: a grievance against imprisonment is heard by the Court of Appeal. An enforcement objection is decided by the enforcement judge in the capacity of a judge of urgent matters (Articles 335 and 363).
- How it is raised: a grievance is made by petition. An enforcement objection may be raised before the enforcement bailiff at the time of enforcement, who then summons the parties to appear before the enforcement judge, or it may be brought directly before the judge (Article 363).
- Effect on enforcement: a grievance against imprisonment does not suspend enforcement of the decision unless the court orders it. With an enforcement objection, the enforcement bailiff may not complete enforcement before the judge rules, and later objections do not suspend enforcement unless the judge orders a suspension, except for the first objection brought by the party bound under the enforceable instrument if it was not a party to an earlier objection or dispute (Article 363).
- Challenge: the decision on a grievance against imprisonment is final. A judgment on an enforcement objection may be appealed within 7 days to the Court of First Instance sitting as a panel of three judges (Article 339).
- Penalty: if the objection suspended enforcement and the objecting party loses, it may be ordered to pay a fine of not less than OMR 10 and not more than OMR 100, without prejudice to compensation (Article 365).
A special case: disputes under the Litigation Procedures Simplification Law
In disputes governed by the Litigation Procedures Simplification Law (in Arabic) issued by Royal Decree 125/2020, including rent disputes, individual labour disputes, building contracts and instruments containing an acknowledgement of debt, judgments in enforcement disputes are appealed to the appellate circuit within 7 days. The circuit decides the appeal within 15 days by a judgment that cannot be challenged, and the appeal does not suspend enforcement unless the circuit so decides (Article 16). Article 17 of that law also sets conditions for notifying the judgment debtor and establishing their refusal before an order is made to arrest or imprison them for debts.
Frequently asked questions
Does a grievance against an imprisonment order suspend it?
No, unless the competent Court of Appeal orders a suspension (Article 418), so it is advisable to ask expressly for a suspension in the petition.
Can the Court of Appeal's decision on a grievance against imprisonment be challenged?
No. Article 418 provides that its decision is final.
What is the period for appealing an enforcement judge's judgment on an enforcement objection?
Seven days from the date the judgment is issued if it was rendered in the appellant's presence, and from the date of notification if it was issued in the appellant's absence. The appeal is brought before the Court of First Instance sitting as a panel of three judges (Article 339).
When does an imprisonment order lapse without a grievance?
Under Article 425, the court orders it to lapse if the judgment creditor agrees in writing, the debt is paid or the obligation is extinguished, a solvent guarantor or a security accepted by the judgment creditor is provided, or the judgment debtor's insolvency is proven by sufficient evidence.
How we can help with enforcement files
Dr. Abdullah Al Rashdi Office, Advocates and Legal Consultants in Al Khuwair, Muscat, handles enforcement files for creditors and debtors. This includes preparing grievance petitions, filing enforcement objections, appealing judgments in enforcement disputes and negotiating settlements. If the problem is a debt that has not yet been collected, see our debt collection for individuals and companies service. For details of our enforcement service, visit the enforcement of judgments page.
Enforcement deadlines are short and may be only a few days. Contact us now on WhatsApp or call +968 92000841 to review your decision and identify the best route to challenge it.
This article is general legal information based on the provisions of the Civil and Commercial Procedure Law and the Litigation Procedures Simplification Law and is not legal advice on a particular case. Every enforcement file has its own circumstances, so we recommend consulting our office before taking any action.

